Tragedy Strikes Princeton: Brotherly Love Turns Deadly
Matthew Hertgen, a 31-year-old Princeton resident, has been accused of murdering his younger brother, Joseph, and the family cat. The incident, reported by Matthew himself.

A Shocking Turn of Events
In a chilling incident that has left the Princeton community reeling, Matthew Hertgen, a 31-year-old resident, has been accused of murdering his younger brother, Joseph, and the family cat. The events unfolded on February 22, 2025, at the Michelle Mews Apartments complex, a place once known for its tranquility. What makes this case even more astonishing is that Matthew himself reported the incident to the authorities, leading them to discover Joseph's body with severe injuries.
Unraveling the Mystery
Matthew faces serious charges, including first-degree murder and weapons offenses, as well as animal cruelty. The investigation is ongoing, with detectives working tirelessly to uncover the motive behind this heinous crime. In a haunting twist, Matthew had shared disturbing poetry online before the incident, which included references to knives and blood—eerily mirroring the crime scene.
Court Proceedings and Mental Health Concerns
Matthew appeared virtually for a pretrial detention hearing, which was rescheduled to allow more time for evidence gathering. His defense team might request a mental health evaluation, given his lack of prior criminal history. This raises questions about the role of mental health in such violent acts and whether there were signs that could have been addressed.
Community in Shock
The incident has sent shockwaves through Princeton, highlighting the unpredictable nature of violent crimes. As the community seeks answers, they also reflect on the need for greater awareness and support for mental health issues. Friends and acquaintances are grappling with the news, describing Matthew as a well-liked individual during his earlier years.
A Call for Reflection
This tragic event serves as a stark reminder of the importance of addressing mental health concerns and the need for support systems within our communities. As the investigation continues, residents are left to ponder the complexities of human behavior and the devastating consequences of unchecked emotions.
Comments ()