Morristown Police Officer Faces DUI Charges After Off-Duty Crash.

In a startling turn of events, an off-duty Morristown police officer, Laura V. Starnes, 22, now finds herself facing serious legal trouble following a late-night crash that has shaken the local community. The incident, which occurred on May 6, 2025, raises important questions about accountability and the responsibilities of those sworn to protect us.

The Crash That Sparked Concern

Just after 11 p.m. on Morris Street near Olyphant Place, Starnes’ vehicle lost control and rolled over in a single-car accident. Thankfully, no other vehicles were involved, and Starnes suffered only minor injuries. However, what caught the attention of responding officers were clear signs that the young officer may have been driving under the influence.

Evidence and Investigation Underway

At the scene, officers noticed indicators of intoxication, prompting them to take Starnes to Morristown Medical Center for a blood draw, which she consented to. While toxicology results are still pending, the Morris County Prosecutor’s Office has already charged her with Driving While Intoxicated and Careless Driving. The case is now in the hands of Madison Municipal Court, where the community awaits justice.

Who is Officer Laura V. Starnes?

Officer Starnes is a relatively new addition to the Morristown Police Department, having joined in December 2024. A Glen Gardner native, she is the daughter of a retired Morris Township police officer, suggesting a family legacy in law enforcement. Starnes graduated from Voorhees High School in 2021 and earned a business degree from Raritan Valley Community College. She became a U.S. citizen in 2021 after emigrating from Colombia, marking a journey of dedication and ambition—now clouded by this unfortunate incident.

Leadership Speaks Out

Morristown Mayor Timothy Dougherty did not mince words when addressing the situation, calling it “serious and deeply troubling.” He stressed the importance of transparency and fairness, recognizing the delicate balance between supporting law enforcement and upholding the law without exception.

The Bigger Picture: Accountability in Policing

This case serves as a powerful reminder that police officers are not above the law. Off-duty misconduct, especially involving impaired driving, threatens the trust between law enforcement and the communities they serve. Holding officers accountable is essential to maintaining that trust and ensuring justice is applied equally.

What’s Next?

As the investigation continues and toxicology results are awaited, Officer Starnes faces a challenging road ahead. The Morristown Police Department is cooperating fully with prosecutors, and the community watches closely as this case unfolds.